LumosTerraBest places to investForumMarketsCalculators

Best places to buy a rental property in Indiana

Ranked by the engine's tracked 5-year appreciation across 23 covered markets in Indiana, snapshot 2026-10-29. Appreciation history is context, not a forecast.
MarketHome value3y5y10yActive listings
Muncie$97,74316.4%55.1%155.2%-
Lafayette$173,63119.4%47.1%160.1%-
Kokomo$111,97528.9%45.6%162.7%-
West Lafayette$373,42224.4%44.5%107.2%-
South Bend$158,54712.7%39.4%137.7%-
East Chicago$113,8242.9%37.6%248.0%-
Elkhart$125,20113.6%36.4%195.4%-
Fort Wayne$184,68712.6%33.5%143.3%-
Marion$139,53418.6%32.6%77.8%-
Goshen$205,09511.8%32.3%111.9%-

Full list: every tracked market in Indiana with 5-year appreciation data below.

All states · Forum

All figures are engine estimates from the LumosTerra tracked-data snapshot as of 2026-10-29. They are starting points, not recommendations - verify rents, comps and local rules before acting on any of them.

Best places to invest in real estate · Real estate investing forum · Pricing