LumosTerraBest places to investForumMarketsCalculators

Best places to buy a rental property in New York

Ranked by the engine's tracked 5-year appreciation across 98 covered markets in New York, snapshot 2026-10-29. Appreciation history is context, not a forecast.
MarketHome value3y5y10yActive listings
Spring Valley$818,15927.8%59.6%136.0%-
Ulster Park$468,72830.8%59.0%139.0%-
Pelham$1,623,40936.3%55.8%91.8%-
Liverpool$221,99026.9%51.7%129.7%-
Sag Harbor$1,847,28321.2%49.9%111.9%-
Woodmere$2,229,84730.3%49.9%113.5%-
New Rochelle$1,283,62826.1%47.9%70.2%-
Jamestown$186,82324.3%47.5%112.0%-
Roslyn$2,122,02925.0%46.4%72.2%-
Sterling$257,48522.4%45.6%101.8%-

Full list: every tracked market in New York with 5-year appreciation data below.

All states · Forum

All figures are engine estimates from the LumosTerra tracked-data snapshot as of 2026-10-29. They are starting points, not recommendations - verify rents, comps and local rules before acting on any of them.

Best places to invest in real estate · Real estate investing forum · Pricing